A remarkable bit of science policy ignorance

Robert Bryce of the Manhattan Institute has clearly not thought terribly hard about the use of science in supporting policy decisions. If he had, he would not have said this (the subject is climate science, but you can substitute anything you want here): The science is not settled, not by a long shot. Last month, …

Continue reading ‘A remarkable bit of science policy ignorance’ »

Stuff I wrote elsewhere: more on our forests burning

Lissa and I are in St. Louis, a wet place. I know it is a wet place because there is no dirt. Or, more specifically, there is no bare dirt. Something’s growing everywhere, the result of 38 inches (97 cm) precipitation per year. I’m always struck by that when I visit a wet place. While …

Continue reading ‘Stuff I wrote elsewhere: more on our forests burning’ »

We’re in trouble when we’re arguing about the numbers

John Bass made a great point in a recent comment thread at Delta National Park that highlights one of my frustrations about California water discussions: [I]f basic facts are contentious, then the problem isn’t facts. The comment was triggered by a point the California Farm Water Coalition’s Mike Wade made regarding an editorial that ran …

Continue reading ‘We’re in trouble when we’re arguing about the numbers’ »

On the relevance of paleoclimate studies

As Irene prepares to drop by and visit our eastern neighbors, Kevin Anchukaitis points to this: Evidence of historical landfalling hurricanes and prehistoric storms has been recovered from backbarrier environments in the New York City area. Overwash deposits correlate with landfalls of the most intense documented hurricanes in the area, including the hurricanes of 1893, …

Continue reading ‘On the relevance of paleoclimate studies’ »

Stuff I Wrote Elsewhere: Why my state is burning down

Richard White’s history of the extension of railroads across the western United States (Railroaded: The Transcontinentals and the Making of Modern America – great read) has fascinating excerpts from the 1870 diary of H.K. Thomas, the Union Pacific stationmaster in Laramie, Wyoming. The normal fires of summer in the mountains are mentioned twice – “covering …

Continue reading ‘Stuff I Wrote Elsewhere: Why my state is burning down’ »

What do we mean by “natural”?

In watching New Mexico’s fires the past few weeks and talking to my forest ecosystem brain trust, I’ve been repeatedly struck by the set of questions Emma Marris raises in her new book Rambunctious Garden (great, recommended) about what baseline we’re thinking about when we talk about restoring natural systems that are currently badly out of …

Continue reading ‘What do we mean by “natural”?’ »

Stuff I Wrote Elsewhere: the big dry, newspaper edition

From the Sunday paper (sub/ad req.*), my attempt to make sense of the issues I was fumbling around about yesterday: The factors that set up trouble in the Southwest’s forests are complex – a warming climate and forest management practices over the 20th century that allowed a terrifying buildup of fuel. There was simply too …

Continue reading ‘Stuff I Wrote Elsewhere: the big dry, newspaper edition’ »

Scientization in the Delta

How vulnerable is the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta to earthquakes? Apparently the answer to that sciency-sounding question depends on your interests in various Delta solution paths. The Delta is a giant, richly entangled example of what Dan Sarewitz talks about: The necessity of looking at nature through a variety of disciplinary lenses brings with it a …

Continue reading ‘Scientization in the Delta’ »