Watermaster, Well Metering Orders on New Mexico’s Middle Rio Grande

The New Mexico Office of State Engineer Friday posted its long-awaited “metering orders,” the first step toward an enhanced regulatory framework to get our arms around who is using water, and how much, along New Mexico’s Middle Rio Grande.

One of the orders formally creates a “water master”:

The District Water Master shall have immediate charge of the apportionment of waters in the District under the general supervision of the State Engineer, and shall appropriate, regulate, and control the waters of the District so as to prevent impairment to senior water right owners and to prevent waste.

The second order also requires metering of groundwater wells. Sort of. Big municipal wells are already metered and regulated. The order would apply to other wells, such as agricultural wells, golf courses, industry (some of those are already metered). Importantly, it does not apply to existing domestic wells, arguably the largest currently unmeasured and therefore unregulated draws on the system:

1. Well owners are required to install totalizing flow meters, on all new and existing groundwater wells within the District in accordance with the standards set out in this Order, with the following exceptions:

a. Existing single wells on a parcel serving solely domestic uses of a single household, including the irrigation of one acre or less of noncommercial trees, lawn, or garden;

b. Existing wells used solely for watering livestock in a grazing operation.

2. The Water Master will require a meter for any well that is not required to have a meter but is deemed likely to have water use exceeding its authorized amount as evidenced by irrigation exceeding one acre, a pond of any size, or activities on site that may result in diversions in excess of authorized amounts.

“1” means new domestic wells all get metered. “2” opens the door for requiring meters on wells irrigating big lots (lots of those in the middle valley!) and ponds, and in general wells that seem to be diverting more than the 1 (for newer domestic wells) or 3 (for older ones) acre feet. Based on our OpenET work, there are likely to be a large number of lots worth triggering “2” for, though structuring the order this ways places the burden on the state to go to each of these thousands of well operators one at a time rather than just placing the burden on all well users to install a meter.

There is a telling allocation of obligation here. The order as written, “deemed likely,” requires an affirmative action by the state, rather than requiring an affirmative action on the part of the water user. This lets little users off the hook for the expense of a meter and reporting, while placing the burden on the state to act in regard to the big users. My hypothesis is that this will result in slow or no action on the many, many big lots on the valley floor that are operating in this legal gray area.

Ponds might be an interesting place to start. They’re pretty obvious.

Quoting Jason Casuga

MRGCD supports the State’s efforts to better understand and address human-driven water depletions in the Middle Rio Grande Valley. This includes the State’s pending metering order and a future evaluation of the cumulative effects of domestic wells. These are important steps toward improved water management and accountability. However, the bosque remains the largest source of water depletion upstream of Elephant Butte Reservoir, yet there is currently no recurring maintenance program or established State targets for managing those depletions.

Middle Rio Grande Conservancy District CEO/Chief Engineer Jason Casuga in an Aug. 19, 2026 letter to New Mexico State Engineer Elizabeth Anderson and Interstate Stream Commission Director Hannah Riseley-White.

Source: MRGCD Sept. 14, 2026 agenda packet

AI as an enabling technology for wildly creative goofballs

From Simon Willison, the guy who brings us pelicans riding bicycles – beep locator!

Our house has a box room, full of boxes that we still haven’t unpacked from our last move. A couple of weeks ago something in that room started intermittently beeping. The beeps were far enough apart that standing in the room and trying to determine the source of the noise was frustrating, and I really didn’t want to dig through every one of those boxes. So I had Claude Code build Beep Locator, a software system for triangulating the source of a mysterious beep using multiple devices scattered around the room.

Turned out it was an old carbon monoxide detector with a dying battery.

As Robin Sloan says, ask for what you want.

Cormorants

Cormorants sitting on wooden posts in a muddy river with trees on the far bank in the background and a "Restoration in Progreess, Please Stay on the Path" sign in the foreground.

Saw four cormorants and four humans fishing at the Albuquerque wastewater treatment plant outfall to the Rio Grande this morning.

Accumlating odds and ends, cluttering my brain but lacking the oomph for a full blog post:

Rio Bravo Bridge

With work getting underway on the replacement of the Rio Bravo Bridge over the Rio Grande in greater Albuquerque’s South Valley, a bit of spelunking in one of the Internet’s unlit subterranean passages yielded this bit of treasure, from a 1992 oral history interview with Jerry Verkler, a former staffer to the late Clinton P. Anderson, who represented New Mexico in the United States Senate from 1949 to 1973.

He made his money in the insurance business, and was a very influential figure in the state of New Mexico selling insurance bonds to highway contractors, etc. But there was a bridge built–the second bridge across the Rio Grande in the valley south of Albuquerque–and it went right across the river about half a mile from his farm–his spread. I always thought that was a happy coincidence. [chuckles] The opportunities are there, and that was one of them that was taken, I guess.

(h/t to my longtime brain trust confidantes S and B for encouraging the spelunking)

Dietrich

Last night’s movie night at the H-F house was a revisit to A Foreign Affair, the 1948 Billy Wilder film about a congressional delegation visiting Berlin during the early years of post-World War II reconstruction. It stands on its own as a terrific film – Jean Arthur is solid, Marlene Dietrich is superb – but the back story is where the real action is.

Wilder left Vienna for Berlin in his early 20s for a career there as a scrappy newspaperman before he began writing screenplays in what was then a competitor with Hollywood in the international cinema. When Hitler began doing Hitler things (“Following Hitler’s rise to power” – the passive voice – seems wrong) Wilder fled first to Paris, then Hollywood. (“It seemed the wise thing for a Jew to do,” he said later. His mother, stepfather, and grandmother were murdered by the Hitler people doing Hitler things.)

Dietrich also made the Berlin-to-Hollywood transit in the 1930s, though she’d already made it as a star in Berlin. She became a U.S. citizen in the late 1930s, refused Nazi offers to return to her native Germany and star in propaganda films for the Hitler people doing Hitler things, helped Wilder to establish a fund to help Jews escape the Hitler people, toured entertaining US troops in Europe, and was in general kind of a badass.

Most of A Foreign Affair was filmed at Paramount in Hollywood, but the film includes devastating footage of a destroyed Berlin that’s real. The opening scene, as the members of Congress are roused from naps to look out the windows of their plane at a devastated, bombed-out Berlin as their plane descends is a classic Wilder setup, he is so good.

Dietrich, in real life the profound anti-Nazi, plays a strong woman surviving – lover to the Nazis when that’s what it takes, lover to the Americans when that’s what it takes. Dietrich’s Erika von Schlütow is one of film’s great badasses, all the more so because of what a badass Dietrich was.

We wondered where we should go now that the war was over. None of us – I mean the émigrés – really knew where we stood. Should we go home? Where was home?

Billy Wilder, quoted in Sikov, Ed. On Sunset Boulevard: The Life and Times of Billy Wilder. Hyperion, 1998.

Bonus bit is Wilder and Dietrich sorta reprieving the character in Witness for the Prosecution, another favorite bit of classic Hollywood.

Power and Progress

Dipped in and out of Daren Acemoglu and Simon Johnson’s Power and Progress, which makes the argument that technological innovation does not, on its own, ensure rising tides and all boats lifting, that there is often concentrated benefit and diffuse costs, but that institutions – the redistribution of benefits through collective action – can eventually overcome the equity challenges.

Relevant to our moment.

Related: dropping back in time to read John Commons’ 1931 paper Institutional Economics. It’s foundational, tries to sort out the flavors of collective action in terms of rules and norms that both liberate and constrain our behaviors in collective action situations through ethics (what’s “right”), economics (what’s advantageous in terms of profits and losses), and jurisprudence (what the state will enforce). Huge connections to our water work, and these ideas have been lurking, but I’ve not read this early literature that laid foundations for folks like Ostrom and Acemoglu who I read today.

Downstream from the wastewater treatment plant

Rode bikes today with collaborator S to see the Rio Bravo Bridge work (see item above) and then down to the wastewater treatment plant outfall. In this year that swung from drought to plenty on the Middle Rio Grande, the stretch of river downstream of the outfall is a fascinating case study. The place with a modest but stable supply of water when the rest of the bosque was parched. What’s up with that?

One thing that’s up is the fishing, apparently. Four cormorants hanging out on snags in the river, four humans fishing at the outfall.

Worth a whole post, or more, maybe a book chapter (we already have way too many chapter ideas for the new book, which is a good problem). For now, clutter cleared.

This year’s El Niño: Past performance is not a guarantee of future returns

Map of the Dec–Feb 2026-27 precipitation forecast: wetter than normal across Arizona, near normal to slightly dry in the Rio Grande and Colorado River headwaters.

November forecast runs from the European Center for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts

It is raining again in Albuquerque, New Mexico, as I type these words.

But the latest forecast from the European Center for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts remains meh for the December-January-February snowpack season across the headwaters of the Rio Grande and the upper reaches of the Colorado River.

Arizona looks wetter.

Bridge Graffiti

Wildstyle graffiti tag with two flanking birds on a bridge abutment

Art on the I25 bridge over the Rio Grande south of Albuquerque, Nov. 1, 2026

The camera on my new phone is dope.

I love bridge abutment graffiti, but it’s so hard to shoot because of the deep shadows and bright light. I love the geometry of the bridge structures, the way it interacts with the writing, the lines and brights and shadows, the three conceptual layers – river, and bridge, and the place making of the art, the social construction of place, as a centerpiece.

This is under the I25 bridge over the Rio Grande on this morning’s bike ride. We were trying to get to the river. The high water was overbanking under the bridge, kept us back a bit. But the bridge art was great.

I’ve struggled with electronic editing to try to overcome the light and shadow problem, with varying success. This is under the 550 Bridge at Bernalillo a couple of months ago, taken with my old phone. The geometry of the light and shadow was amazing, a Sheeler moment, but there was no way for me to get the graffiti without blowing out the morning sun on the river and far bank.

Graffiti on a bridge abutment, water in the foreground, and angled light and shadow.

550 Bridge, Bernalillo, New Mexico, September 2026.

The new camera has some dynamic range magic going on in its image processing as I’m shooting that is, as I said, dope.

Quoting Daniel Swain

Daniel Swain on the next wave of Four Corners storms expected this weekend (Halloween 2026):

The fact that this pair of back-to-back extreme-to-record shattering rain events across the interior Southwest have occurred during the autumn during (one of the) strongest El Niño events on record is not a coincidence! Such events are known to be amplifed by 1) unusually warm ocean waters in the eastern subtropical Pacific, 2) increased East Pacific tropical cyclone activity, and 3) a strengthened early-season subtropical jet in this region–all of which are much more likely to occur under strong El Niño conditions. We also know that climate change has warmed both the atmosphere and oceans–raising the ceiling on how much moisture can be in the air when it is saturated, as in a storm cloud, and thus also the ceiling on extreme precipitation intensity. When natural climate cycles (e.g., El Niño) align with the effects of long-term human-caused warming (i.e., climate change), this is precisely when we should expect to see an increased possibility of historically unprecedented hydroclimate extremes.

Rio Puerco in full glory

The Rio Puerco (the eastern one, there’s two, this is the one that flows into the Rio Grande south of Belen, New Mexico) took its turn yesterday, with historic flows from the tropical storm remnants that have been drenching the Four Corners states. I have no idea who Jon Finley is, but we’re forever in his debt (h/t Paul Tashjian at Audubon for sharing):

Farmington flood

Shaded-relief map of the San Juan River from Navajo Dam to Farmington, N.M. Peak flows climb from 2,190 cfs below the dam to 13,100 at Bloomfield, 17,100 at Bolack Ranch Bridge, and about 32,600 at Farmington, where gages failed. The ungaged Cañon Largo and Gobernador Canyon watersheds are outlined.

A flood for the ages.

The group chat among my Colorado River posse blew up again this morning as the nerds compared reservoir and stream gage readings resulting from a storm for the ages in the Four Corners.

Staring at gages, you can see the wave of water coming down the San Juan. The gage at Bloomfield blew out late Thursday night, reading 13,100 cubic feet per second (cfs) before it failed. Downstream, the wave blew out the gage at the Bolack Ranch Bridge 7 hours later, running at 17,100 cfs. By the time the USGS gage on the San Juan at Farmington blew out Friday afternoon, the river had risen to ~32,600 cfs, the most water recorded there since the 1930s and more than double the biggest peak since Navajo Dam was completed in the early 1960s.

Flooding stretched from Pagosa Springs on the San Juan River in Colorado to Dennehotso on the Navajo Nation, with what appears to be the greatest impact on human communities in the Northwest New Mexico community of Farmington, at the confluence of the Animas and San Juan rivers. (The Tri-City Record seems to be the go-to source for news out of Farmington, also Patrick Lohmann at SourceNM, local and regional journalism FTW.) The report everyone keeps citing in news stories, via the National Weather Service, from late morning yesterday (Friday, Oct. 23), cites Farmington-area law enforcement saying “As many as 1500 homes and buildings are estimated to be impacted by flooding.” That’s 24 hours old.

At 11 a.m. this morning (Saturday, Oct. 24), they closed the Highway 64 bridge over the San Juan in Shiprock after the San Juan overtopped the bridge.

I’m only loosely familiar with the area, and I’m not on the ground up there, but based on the gage readings and reports from emergency managers it looks like most of the water came out of two normally dry tributaries – Gobernador Canyon (a 111-square-mile watershed) and the much larger Cañon Largo (1,714 square miles). This is mostly a process of elimination – the gage below the Bureau of Reclamation’s Navajo Dam peaked at 2,190 cfs Thursday night, which puts an upper bound on the release. Gobernador and Largo are the most plausible ungaged watersheds between the dam and Bloomfield. Also, there was a report of flooding and evacuations in Largo Wash and Gobernador Canyon Thursday evening at 5:39 p.m., less than 6 hours before the Bloomfield gage went dark. The Animas at Farmington was only adding ~8,000 cfs Friday when the gage on the San Juan hit ~32,600 cfs and stopped reporting.

One of the lessons I learned as a young journalist covering earthquakes in California is that the places identified as having the most damage from a natural disaster are not necessarily the worst-hit places. They’re often the places that are the worst hit and still have the ability to communicate. This is sparsely populated Navajo and Jicarilla Apache Country, and I’d assume that the danger and the damage we’re hearing about from the population centers does not tell the full story of the suffering underway in the region.

Climate and flooding

We have three different primary kinds of flooding in the interior arid Southwestern United States: from spring and summer snowmelt; localized flooding from the summer monsoons; and autumn tropical storm remnants. We’re now experiencing a wave of classic tropical storm remnants.

The moisture that hit the Four Corners came from the remnants of Hurricane Trudy, which skirted the west coast of Mexico Oct. 16-19. This is not a visit from the hurricane itself, but rather its remnant moisture being pulled into the storm track, providing massive moisture fuel for what follows.

A group led by Elizabeth Ritchie at the University of Arizona some years back quantified the impact these storms can have:[1]

Although the tropical cyclone–strength winds rapidly diminish upon making landfall, these systems still carry a large quantity of tropical moisture and, upon interaction with mountainous topography, are found to drop up to 30% of the local annual precipitation.

Much like the summer monsoon, the impact of climate change on this kind of storm in the future is challenging to understand because these storms happen at spatial scales that are difficult for General Circulation Models, the big climate models used to understand the effects of rising greenhouse gases, to resolve. The coarse resolution of the GCMs tends to underestimate how much precipitation comes from the biggest storms – this is an issue I wrote about back in my science journalism days in the ’00s. We have new higher resolution GCMs now, but they still seem to struggle with this.[2]


  1. Ritchie, Elizabeth A., Kimberly M. Wood, David S. Gutzler, and Sarah R. White. “The influence of eastern Pacific tropical cyclone remnants on the southwestern United States.” Monthly Weather Review 139, no. 1 (2011): 192-210. ??

  2. Bjarke, Nels R., Ben Livneh, Joseph J. Barsugli, Angeline G. Pendergrass, and Eric E. Small. “Evaluating Large-Storm Dominance in High-Resolution GCMs and Observations Across the Western Contiguous United States.” Earth’s Future 12, no. 6 (2024): e2023EF004289. https://doi.org/10.1029/2023EF004289. ??

When people have less water, they seem to use less water

Green acreage in non-Pueblo MRGCD irrigable parcels, summer 2026

Bar chart of green area across the whole Middle Rio Grande Conservancy District, summers 2017 to 2026. Green area falls slowly from 36.2 to 32.7 thousand acres between 2017 and 2024, drops to 27.6 thousand in 2025, and falls to 17.3 thousand in 2026, the lowest of the ten years.

Area of green land in the non-Pueblo Middle Rio Grande Conservancy District, summers 2017–2026. Bars give the area of 10 m Sentinel-2 pixels with median June–August NDVI ? 0.45, summed over the 10,551 parcels of the district’s 2021 irrigation survey (58,145 acres; right axis expresses area as a percentage of that total). Error bars show the same count at NDVI cuts of 0.50 (lower) and 0.40 (upper); they express sensitivity to the cut, not a statistical interval. The parcel boundaries are fixed at their 2021 extent in every year, so each bar is the green area within those parcels, not a survey of that summer. *2021 is the year the cut was calibrated against the survey’s recorded irrigation labels. NDVI cannot distinguish irrigation by canal, well or municipal supply from shallow groundwater or rainfall. 2026 is highlighted (17.3 thousand acres; 13.9–21.2 across the cut range, against 36.2 thousand acres in 2017). Data: Copernicus Sentinel-2 surface reflectance (ESA), scene-classification cloud mask, summer median composite; parcels from the MRGCD 2021 ISOlog. Methodology caption written by Claude.

2026 provided a remarkable convergence of a natural experiment on New Mexico’s Middle Rio Grande (a river and therefore irrigation system with little or no water) and the rapid advancement of what I’ve come to think of as “Curiosity Exploder Tools” (CETs, also more commonly known as LLMs or AI).

We’ve got European Space Agency satellites flying overhead every five-ish days hoovering up data, Google Earth Engine processing power in “the cloud,” and now tools like Codex and Claude Code to handle the fiddly bits of code writing, driving down the transaction costs of asking a question by orders of magnitude.

So I wondered: With little or no Middle Rio Grande Conservancy District ditch water for non-Prior and Paramount Pueblo land this year, what happened? As Robin Sloan said, “‘Ask for what you want’ is a key skill for the 21st century.”

We don’t have meters on irrigated land in the Middle Rio Grande, so remote sensing is the best we can do.

This uses MRGCD’s spatial mapping of irrigated parcels, with Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), a measure of plant greenness, using observations from the European Space Agency’s Sentinel-2 satellites. 10 meter resolution roughly every five days. “Green” here is not an either/or, it’s a more-or-less thing. I chose an NDVI cutoff based on a reading of 0.45, benchmarked against an MRGCD dataset from 2021 of parcels either irrigated or fallowed. The cutoff is arbitrary (but sane based on my 2021 control set), the relative scale is what matters.

The satellite can’t tell us the difference among ditch water, wells (both irrigation and domestic), municipal water, and trees with their roots in the shallow aquifer. But as I wrote with a group of colleagues earlier this year, “Agencies don’t use water, people do.” All four can be present on these parcels. I checked precipitation, it’s not throwing off the numbers.

I’ve now got a stunning set of maps of this on my hard drive – MRGCD non-Pueblo land by division and sub-section, year by year – a record of how people are greening the valley ditch by ditch and parcel by parcel. As Robin Sloan said, ask for what you want. Curiosity Exploder Tools.

However you interpret it, the satellite data suggests a significant reduction in 2026 consumptive use of water on these parcels, a remarkable water conservation success story, if you will.

n.b. “Study” design by John Fleck in conversation with Claude Code, data processing pipeline by Claude Code with Google Earth Engine analysis.